Skip to main content

Persimmon has announced an acceleration of its Capital Return Plan, but shockingly, made no mention of the resulting acceleration of zero-cost options now estimated to be worth £500million to management. With options previously vested the total becomes £600million. The Finance Director alone will receive £72million.

Great news for investors perhaps, that dividends will reach 900p in the plan period, up from 620p, but the ten-year Long Term Incentive Plan approved in October 2012 will now, with just a minor 50p tweak in the announced programme, become a less-than-six-year plan. There is no hint of numbers of this magnitude in any published announcement.

What is wrong with this? The answer is, a lot:
• The company is not being open about it.
• The full value and its implications have never been acknowledged by the company (which resisted UKSA’s attempt to seek transparency).
• Poor stewardship by the company’s fund management shareholders failed to curb this hugely excessive transfer of value from their investors to the company’s managers.
• Poorly worded remuneration reporting regulations (against which UKSA has protested) have allowed this to go unnoticed.
• It’s hard to see how financial statements that ignore this transfer of value, equal to a full year’s net profit, can be said to present a ‘true and fair view’ as stated by the directors in their recent announcement of 2015 results.
• It’s hard to see how accounting standards that allow this transfer of value to be ignored can be fit for purpose in this respect.

Anaysis of the £500million here
UKSA’s 2013 review of this LTIP here
UKSA’s 2014 review of this LTIP here
Financial Reporting Council’s comment on ‘true and fair view’ here

Renew your membership

Renewing your UKSA membership is quick and easy, ensuring uninterrupted access to all the advantages of membership.

Responsible Investing



"Cogent, relevant, well-informed, astute and important" The Times

Click here to view


The Private Investor


Click here to view